Third World, Modernization, Religion

Name:
Location: Germany

I’m a Ph.D. student of Sociology in Germany. I did read somewhere that Weblogs today are more functional than thesis committee. I would like to know how it works for my thesis about fate of Religion in the epoch of Modernity specially in the Third World.

Friday, March 13, 2009

Sexual native selection at university in Iran, An obstacle to progress of the girl students

My father was saying you must just study at our city’s university, if you want to study. It took several months until I proved at last his satisfaction to choose other cities, but on the results of the competitive examination, I was not selected. Asking around, I did understand that there is a new law: the girls must study just at their very own city’s university.
This says Nastaran, a 18 years old girl from Booshehr.
She wanted to study at an excellent university, find a job, and be independent but now all of these are just a far dream.
Owing to the fact that percentage of girls accepted at university increased and they outstripped the boys, the state and the parliament cause from time to time some problems to progress of educated women.
The proposition of sexual quota of university, which was in 2004 on the agenda of the parliament, was aborted through protest of activist women and by order of the president Khatami.
But the 7th parliament in governance era of the 9th state ran again the proposition and tried to prevent, as much possible, educated women from ascent. While the protest continued, the girls and their family were shocked again by the parliament. According to the new proposition called “obligation of university to acceptance of girls student at their residency”, Sazman Sanjesh(the government agency responsible for university entrance exams) and Islamic Azad university must adopt a policy that female candidates, far as possible be accepted near their residency. According to representatives, if this proposition be enacted, it will apply next year. Nevertheless according to authorities of Sazman Sanjesh it also was regarded this year without giving information to applicants.
“General policy of student selection is a legislation of the Higher Council of Cultural Revolution and Sazman Sanjesh set accordingly native selection on the table”, said Ali Karimi Firouzjaei, a commissioner of the parliament’s education and research commission. He stresses that the importance of the matter is double for women because from the viewpoint of the proposer a woman must study in her husband’s or father’s residency.
According to this point of view sees Asadollah Badamchian, a representative of Tehran, the proposition as a gift of 8th parliament to families. He claims that girl’s further education outside of their residence has a lot of problems for girls and this useful & effective plan will solve them.
But on the other side many young girls have another opinion. Female students that don’t study in their residence see studentship as a golden opportunity to value individuality and their talent.
Samira, a second year engineering student of the University of Tehran finds living in a hostel a unique experience that helps to be free from heavy dominance of patriarchal traditions and to be the decision-maker in her life. “If I was still in Kermanshah, it was impossible to progress so much, to read, to see, and to realize the world.” Says Samira.
Zohreh has gone from Tehran to Kerman. “Although Kerman hasn’t good facilities like Tehran but it gave me chance of independent life. Furthermore it was impossible to study engineering at the University of Tehran with such low score like mine, then I had to marry at the request of my parents,” Says Zohreh.
She believes that education is the only way for girls to come in to the society and to be free from the pressure of a traditional community: “enforcement the policy like nativization decreases strongly the variety choice for girls. If, for any reason, they can’t or don’t want to study at their own city, they must abandon entry to the society and being independent.”

Moreover, university’s facilities in Tehran and large cities are incomparable with other cities, so enforcement of this plan deprives the half of country population from studying at advanced universities, just because they are women!
The proposition of “obligation of universities to acceptance of girls student at their residency” is still not adopted and women activists specially girls student attempt hardly to prevent it.
The Women’s Committee of Tahkim-e Vahdat protested through publishing a brochure against native selection and sexual quota. In this brochure that distributed by students in past few days in some universities in Tehran, the citizens are requested to show their complaint against this unjust plan to the authorities: “if the proposition be adapted, provincial girl applicants don’t have the right to continue education in Tehran and other big cities. It deprives not only provincial girl applicants from continuing their education in Tehran, but also forbids girl applicants of Tehran from studying some popular subjects like medicine, engineering, and law in other large cities, as native selection in competitive examination of 2008 forbad many male and female candidates from studying their favourite subjects at excellent university. If it be adapted, sexual discrimination in educational system will be institutionalized. Sexual discrimination takes the opportunity from girls to improve their social identity. If it be adapted, it prohibits social and class mobility, dams different cultures to grow and to be in contact, and reduces rate of development.” The brochure stresses that: “enforcement of such limitations contradicts obviously with article 21 Iran’s constitution. According to the constitution, the state has a duty to improve women character and resurrect her material & spiritual rights through preparing suitable conditions.”

Marjan Hoseini (Shahrzad News)
Translated by Reza

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Again the matter of adviser

I don’t know what I should do with my adviser. After 9 months he says still new points about my expose. Every time he makes new critique on what he said ok before that. Unfortunately there isn’t any other adviser in my favourite field. Last time I said I don’t have a job and don’t have a scholarship and time is very important for me. He said it is better to do not consider such problems; otherwise I must give a letter of agreement to all people that have problem!!!
I recommend you don’t come here to study.

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

Two Perspective of Modernization

Many of sociologists of religion have claimed that religion in modern era die out. Max Weber attributed this phenomenon to the scientific knowledge. Lerner, Inkeles, and Smith emphasized too from a cognitive perspective to the role of high level of education in modernization.

There is another perspective, namely to call existential. Turning point of this trend is economic development. Accordingly, in "Modernization, Cultural Change, and Democracy" Inglehatr and Welzel argue: the higher level of economic development, the lower belief in religion. It means religion survives and its existence is, at least in poor countries taken for granted.

But I want ask just a simple question:
Why religion is in some rich Islamic countries among others Saudi Arabia and Kuwait alive, active, and firm?

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

What causes democracy?

Value change is an interesting and at the same time a problematic topic for sociology.
One of the most challenging themes today is the matter of autocracy and democracy. How change a governmental system in a country? What role dose people play in this process? What causes democracy?
Inglehart, among others, tried to answer these questions. In many of his works that come out from several waves of World Values Survey he speaks about political culture. According to Inglehart political culture has a main role and it causes democracy. Political culture insist of well-being, happiness, self-expression, life satisfaction interpersonal trust, tolerance with out groups, freedom of speech, political activism and etc. He calls this political culture ”self-expression values”. He and his collaborates argue that self-expression values conducive democracy. Self-expression values are necessarily condition for democracy but they aren’t sufficiently condition for it.
Economic development is the mean factor. With other word: Economic development > self-expression values > democracy

Without economic development there is no democracy.

Thursday, October 9, 2008

Culture and Democracy

Inglehart in „Culture and Democracy“ says that economic development correlates strongly with democracy, it means the higher GNP/capita in a country is, the more likely the people want to have a democratic government. But high GNP or good economic situation generally is not the only precondition of democracy. Social and political values, history of the country and some other elements play a big role in this process.
Among others, religion is very important in the process of democratization. Inglehart in his cultural map of the world shows how different religions have a different impact on the people and the cultural map.

Monday, September 8, 2008

Ph.D. adviser

I’m not sure what to do?
In 4 months ago I did my best and I wrote my expose'. Every time the professor said some new points about it. At least the expose’ was very good and he had nothing to say but he said you must visit one course for doctorate program and after 6 month we see us in February and than talk about your thesis!!!
I’m very confused. He changed my theme, my method and all other things and now said after one semester!
At the beginning of the study someone has told me finding a PhD adviser in Germany is a catastrophe. I said don’t be so pessimistic! Now I find out that he was right!!!

Monday, June 30, 2008

Years of Democracy

Hi there

Is there anyone who knows how man can find „years of democracy „for countries around the world? I wanna compare age of democracy in different countries. From years of democracy I mean how long one contry under democratic government is.